In-House vs Outsourced XHS Marketing: Which Delivers Better Results for Malaysian Brands?
Xiaohongshu, commonly known as XHS or RED, has become an increasingly important platform for Malaysian brands looking to reach Chinese-speaking consumers through authentic, search-driven content. From beauty and fashion to food and beverage, hospitality, retail, and lifestyle, brands are using XHS to influence how consumers discover, research, and evaluate products before making a purchase.
However, succeeding on Xiaohongshu requires more than simply creating an account and publishing content regularly. Brands need to understand the platform’s content culture, search behaviour, creator ecosystem, visual language, and the expectations of its predominantly Chinese-speaking audience. This is where XHS Marketing becomes particularly important.
One of the biggest decisions Malaysian brands face is whether to manage their XHS Marketing strategy internally or outsource it to a specialised agency. An in-house team may offer greater control and direct communication, while an outsourced agency can provide specialised expertise, established creator relationships, and broader campaign resources.
Neither approach is automatically the right choice for every brand. The better option depends on factors such as budget, internal expertise, campaign objectives, content requirements, and how seriously the brand intends to invest in Xiaohongshu as a long-term marketing channel.
This guide explores the key differences between in-house and outsourced XHS Marketing and examines which approach may deliver better results for Malaysian brands.
What Does In-House XHS Marketing Involve?
In-house XHS Marketing means that a brand’s own internal marketing team is responsible for managing its Xiaohongshu presence and campaigns. This typically includes content planning, account management, copywriting, visual production, community management, KOL coordination, campaign reporting, and performance optimisation.
For brands that already have an experienced Chinese-speaking social media or digital marketing team, managing XHS internally can provide a high level of control. Team members are directly involved in the brand every day, allowing them to understand its products, positioning, tone of voice, and long-term objectives in considerable depth.
This approach can work particularly well for larger companies with sufficient resources to dedicate specific personnel to XHS. It can also be attractive for brands that want Xiaohongshu to become a permanent part of their marketing ecosystem rather than simply using it for occasional campaigns.
However, having a social media team does not necessarily mean having XHS expertise. Xiaohongshu operates differently from platforms such as Instagram, Facebook, or TikTok. Content that performs well elsewhere may not automatically perform well on XHS, and teams may need time to develop a strong understanding of the platform’s search behaviour, content formats, audience expectations, and creator ecosystem.
What Does Outsourced XHS Marketing Involve?
Outsourced XHS Marketing involves working with an external agency or specialist team to manage some or all aspects of a brand’s Xiaohongshu strategy.
Depending on the agency, services can include account strategy, content creation, Chinese copywriting, KOL identification, influencer campaigns, product seeding, community management, paid media, campaign optimisation, and performance reporting.
The main advantage is access to specialised knowledge without requiring the brand to build an entirely new internal team. An experienced XHS Marketing agency may already understand the platform’s content trends, audience behaviour, creator landscape, and campaign requirements.
For Malaysian brands, this can be particularly valuable when targeting Chinese-speaking consumers. An agency with local market knowledge can help bridge the gap between a brand’s overall marketing strategy and the specific cultural and content expectations of Malaysian XHS users.
Instead of learning the platform from scratch, brands can leverage an existing team that already works within the XHS ecosystem.
In-House vs Outsourced XHS Marketing: Which Costs More?
Cost is naturally one of the first factors Malaysian brands consider when deciding between in-house and outsourced XHS Marketing.
At first glance, managing XHS internally may appear more affordable because the brand is not paying an external agency retainer. However, the actual cost of building an in-house operation can extend well beyond employee salaries.
Brands may need to hire Chinese-speaking content writers, designers, social media specialists, video creators, KOL managers, and performance marketers. They may also need to invest in training, software, creator databases, production equipment, and ongoing platform research.
For smaller businesses, hiring multiple specialists may not be financially practical.
Outsourcing can provide access to these capabilities through a single team. Although an agency requires a service fee, brands may avoid the cost and complexity of recruiting and managing several specialised employees.
The most useful comparison therefore is not simply the agency fee versus an employee’s salary. Brands should consider the total cost of achieving the same level of XHS Marketing expertise internally.
Which Approach Provides Better XHS Expertise?
Expertise is one of the biggest differences between an internal and outsourced approach.
XHS Marketing requires an understanding of how users search for information, what types of posts generate saves and engagement, how keywords should be incorporated into content, how visual presentation influences discovery, and what types of creator collaborations resonate with the platform’s audience.
An in-house team may eventually develop this expertise, but it takes time and practical experience. A team that primarily specialises in Instagram, TikTok, or Facebook may need to go through a learning curve before it understands how XHS differs from other social platforms.
A specialist XHS Marketing agency, on the other hand, can potentially provide this expertise immediately. Agencies working across multiple brands may also have access to broader performance data and experience across different industries.
For Malaysian brands that are new to Xiaohongshu, this specialised knowledge can significantly reduce the trial-and-error involved in developing an effective strategy.
Content Creation: In-House Control vs Specialist Production
Content is at the heart of XHS Marketing. The platform is heavily driven by visually appealing, informative, and searchable posts, meaning brands need to think carefully about both presentation and substance.
An in-house team has the advantage of being deeply familiar with the brand. They can produce content quickly, make immediate changes, and maintain consistent brand guidelines across campaigns.
However, internal teams may struggle if they do not have experience creating content specifically for Chinese-speaking XHS audiences. Simply translating an English or Malay caption into Chinese is unlikely to produce the same result as creating content specifically for the platform.
Outsourced XHS Marketing teams can bring specialised Chinese copywriting, content strategy, photography, video production, and platform knowledge to the process. They can also help adapt existing brand assets into formats that are more suitable for Xiaohongshu.
The strongest approach is not necessarily the one that produces the most content, but the one that produces content that feels native to XHS while remaining recognisable as part of the brand.
KOL Marketing: Is Outsourcing More Effective?
KOL Marketing is one area where the difference between in-house and outsourced XHS Marketing can become particularly significant.
Finding suitable Xiaohongshu creators requires more than searching for accounts with large follower counts. Brands need to evaluate audience demographics, engagement quality, content style, category relevance, previous collaborations, and the authenticity of creator recommendations.
An internal team can certainly build these relationships over time, particularly if XHS is an important long-term channel. However, developing a reliable network of relevant KOLs requires substantial research and relationship management.
Specialist agencies may already have established relationships with creators across different categories and follower tiers. This can make it easier to identify suitable KOLs and execute campaigns involving multiple creators simultaneously.
For Malaysian brands running large-scale KOL Marketing campaigns, outsourcing can therefore reduce the administrative workload while giving the brand access to a broader creator ecosystem.
Speed and Scalability
Another important consideration is how quickly a brand needs to scale its XHS Marketing activities.
An in-house team may be highly effective when managing a relatively stable content calendar. However, campaign requirements can change quickly during product launches, festive seasons, promotional periods, or major collaborations.
If a brand suddenly needs to work with 20 or 50 KOLs, produce dozens of pieces of content, or launch a major seasonal campaign, the internal team may quickly become stretched.
An outsourced XHS Marketing agency can potentially scale resources according to campaign requirements. Additional creators, content producers, account managers, and campaign specialists can be brought into the project without the brand needing to permanently expand its internal headcount.
This flexibility can be particularly useful for Malaysian brands that experience significant peaks in demand around occasions such as Chinese New Year, Hari Raya, 11.11, 12.12, and major product launches.
Control and Communication
Despite the advantages of outsourcing, in-house XHS Marketing has one important strength: direct control.
Internal teams can communicate immediately, make decisions quickly, and access product information without going through an external party. This can be valuable for brands with strict approval processes or complex brand guidelines.
Outsourcing introduces another layer of communication. Brands need to provide clear briefs, establish approval procedures, and maintain regular communication with their agency.
However, this does not necessarily mean that outsourcing results in less control. A strong agency partnership should establish clear reporting structures, content approval processes, campaign objectives, and communication channels from the beginning.
The key is choosing an agency that treats itself as an extension of the brand rather than simply an external content supplier.
Measuring the Results of XHS Marketing
Regardless of whether XHS Marketing is managed internally or externally, performance measurement should remain a central part of the strategy.
Brands should evaluate metrics such as post views, likes, comments, saves, shares, follower growth, profile visits, search visibility, website traffic, enquiries, and conversions where measurable.
The importance of each metric depends on the campaign objective. A brand awareness campaign may prioritise reach and visibility, while a product-launch campaign may focus more heavily on engagement, product-page visits, enquiries, and sales.
Outsourced agencies may have an advantage when it comes to benchmarking performance because they can draw from experience across multiple campaigns and industries. An internal team, however, can develop equally valuable insights over time if it consistently tracks results and documents what works.
The most important factor is not who manages the campaign, but whether the brand has a clear system for measuring performance and using those insights to improve future campaigns.
When Should Malaysian Brands Choose In-House XHS Marketing?
In-house XHS Marketing may be the better option for brands that already have a strong Chinese-speaking marketing team, sufficient content-production resources, and a long-term commitment to building Xiaohongshu expertise internally.
It can also make sense for brands that require extremely close control over their messaging, have frequent content requirements, and are prepared to invest in training and specialist talent.
For these businesses, building internal XHS expertise can become a valuable long-term asset. The team gradually develops its own knowledge, creator relationships, content library, and performance database.
However, brands should be realistic about the resources required. Assigning XHS responsibilities to an existing social media employee without providing specialist training or additional resources may result in an account that technically remains active but fails to achieve meaningful growth.
When Should Malaysian Brands Outsource XHS Marketing?
Outsourcing may be more suitable for brands that are new to Xiaohongshu, lack Chinese-speaking specialists, want to launch campaigns quickly, or need access to KOL networks without building those relationships from scratch.
It can also be valuable for brands that want to test XHS before making a significant internal investment. Rather than immediately hiring a full team, a brand can work with an agency to determine whether the platform generates meaningful results for its target audience.
For companies managing multiple marketing channels simultaneously, outsourcing can also allow the internal team to focus on broader business and marketing priorities while specialists manage the day-to-day requirements of XHS.
Ultimately, the right decision depends on the brand’s objectives, resources, and expected level of investment.
The Case for Working With a XHS Marketing Agency
For many Malaysian brands, the biggest advantage of outsourcing XHS Marketing is the ability to access specialised expertise without building an entire internal operation.
A specialist agency can manage strategy, content creation, Chinese copywriting, KOL Marketing, creator negotiations, campaign coordination, performance tracking, and optimisation under one structure. This can make the process significantly more efficient for brands that lack dedicated XHS resources.
An experienced agency can also help brands avoid common mistakes, such as simply translating existing social media content, selecting KOLs based only on follower counts, or treating Xiaohongshu like Instagram or TikTok.
At Envisage Digital Space, we help Malaysian brands develop and manage XHS Marketing strategies designed specifically for the Chinese-speaking consumer market. From content strategy and KOL identification to campaign management and performance reporting, our team provides end-to-end support for brands looking to build a stronger presence on Xiaohongshu.
Conclusion
There is no universal answer to whether in-house or outsourced XHS Marketing delivers better results. The right approach depends on a brand’s internal expertise, budget, campaign requirements, and long-term commitment to Xiaohongshu.
In-house teams offer control, brand familiarity, and the ability to develop internal expertise over time. Outsourced agencies provide specialised knowledge, creator relationships, scalability, and access to resources without requiring brands to build an entire XHS operation themselves.
For Malaysian brands that are new to Xiaohongshu or lack dedicated Chinese-speaking specialists, outsourcing can provide a faster and more efficient path to establishing a strong presence. For larger brands with sufficient resources and a long-term commitment to the platform, developing an internal team may eventually make sense.
Ultimately, successful XHS Marketing is less about who manages the account and more about whether the strategy understands the platform, its users, and the way Malaysian consumers discover and evaluate brands on Xiaohongshu.
If your brand is deciding between managing XHS Marketing internally or working with a specialist agency, Envisage Digital Space can help you develop a strategy that matches your objectives, audience, and resources.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is in-house or outsourced XHS Marketing better for Malaysian brands?
Neither approach is universally better. In-house XHS Marketing can provide greater control and long-term internal expertise, while outsourcing gives brands access to specialised knowledge, KOL networks, and scalable resources. The better option depends on the brand's budget, team capabilities, and objectives.
How much does outsourced XHS Marketing cost in Malaysia?
The cost of outsourced XHS Marketing varies depending on the agency, campaign scope, content requirements, KOL involvement, posting frequency, and campaign duration. Brands should evaluate the total services and resources included rather than comparing agencies based solely on monthly fees.
Can a Malaysian brand manage Xiaohongshu without an agency?
Yes. Brands can manage Xiaohongshu internally if they have the necessary Chinese-language, content, platform, and marketing expertise. However, teams unfamiliar with XHS may require additional training and resources to develop an effective long-term strategy.
What does an XHS Marketing agency typically do?
An XHS Marketing agency can provide services such as account strategy, content planning, Chinese copywriting, content creation, KOL Marketing, influencer outreach, campaign management, community engagement, and performance reporting, depending on the agency's services.
When should a Malaysian brand outsource its XHS Marketing?
Outsourcing can be particularly useful when a brand is new to Xiaohongshu, lacks Chinese-speaking specialists, needs to launch campaigns quickly, or wants access to an established KOL network without building one internally.









